Friends w/Benefits
Recently, I met someone who has tempted me to try friends with benefits again. What I had forgotten was how messy this all can be. I have done this fairly successfully several times in my life. The first time, C. was a friend of over three years before he jumped me one night sitting outside of a natural foods market. Ah the romance of the moment. :) We ended up slowly falling in love and were together for many years. The second was very carefully chosen. I was still fairly heartbroken from C., but I was ready to explore my dark side. So I chose B. to be my mentor and friend in a mutual exploration of BDSM. We saw each other for most of a year on and off, but it was never really romantic- I think for either of us. Just good dirty fun. Yea fun! Then there was J. He struggled with what the restrictions of this kind of relationship might mean. I think he knew he would never fall in love with me, and that inspired a certain guilt. I don't think either of us knew how much of a romantic he was. So how did all of those turn out: C. and I still talk fairly often and will probably always be friends with no bennies ever again, B. is for the first time in his polyamorous life semi serious and exclusive with a new partner, though we talk occasionally, and J. is a friend and now falling deeply for his current partner, and that pleases me more than I can begin to tell you.
So now comes along this very interesting man into my life. I don't know him well, and he knows me perhaps even less. :) But he is, so far, a very good match for the type of men I like to date: funny, smart, attractive, educated, open minded, highly sexual and just a little fucked up. But he is completely undatable. He is just out of a relationship, and I have never been fond of being rebound girl. (faster than a speeding bullet they leave her behind, or worse they move in and whine!) I am getting the impression that he thinks I am interested in more than a casual relationship. So being rather the geek woman that I am, I spent some time doing research to see where I was maybe going wrong.
I began with three books read in this order: The Ethical Slut, a Guide to Infinite Sexual Possibilities by Dossie Easton and Catherine A. Liszt, The Happy Hook-Up, a Single Girl's Guide to Casual Sex by Alexa Joy Sherman and Nicole Tocantins, and The Hookup Handbook, a Single Girl's Guide to Living it up by Andrea Lavinthal and Jessica Rozler. The latter two are both new in the last few months, but the first has been out since 1997. Oddly enough, it's this older book that offered me more wisdom, even though it is not really exactly on the topic.
The Ethical Slut is something of a classic now on the many variations people live in sexually, and especially a guide to polyamorous relationships. It is a wonderful read and can help you stretch you mind, even if you are like me and don't generally live or want to live polyamorously. "Ethical sluts are honest - with ourselves and others," was their first piece of advice I examined. I have been very honest with this gentleman, but it is probably way too early to expect him to really understand how brutually forthright I am. "We believe ... That the fundamental sexual unit is one person ... A fundamental step in ethical sluthood is to bring your locus of control into yourself ... We call this integrity." This one I like a lot, partially due to the wonderful two definitions associated with integrity. Except for some sexual playacting, I have never wanted to be in control of anyone else, dealing with me has been enough of a challenge and joy in and of itself. Throughout the book, they talk about finding your own limits and scripts. Easton talks quite openly about realizing that, "she does not share sex with anyone that she's not at least potentially interested in sharing sex with again, and anything worth doing is worth waiting till the time is right." This suits me well, as I do not like the whole one night stand approach to my own sexuality. I prefer taking the time to see how far two people can take this between them when playing. The second half, I agree with, but sometimes my desires take me too far too fast. On the topic of "mindful choices" and fuck buddies they basically affirm that you can love them as friends and lovers without ever wanting to become committed to those individuals on an exclusive basis. I find I am enough of a romantic to believe in exclusivity when you find someone worthy of it and who thinks the same of you. But until such time, I am very comfortable with enjoying the men whom I choose, and even with a touch of love.
The other two titles, The Happy Hook-Up and The Hookup Handbook, surprised me with how little they had to offer me in terms of advice. If you are looking for information about hooking up and like a lot of it, I recommend the first. If you are a teenager, or very young and tragedically hip and have little time, try the second. The handbook has very large print, a sense of humor, and covers most of the basics. Where they fail utterly- is to give enough time and discussion to the risks and safe sex. One quote of theirs I do like, "If dating is a book, then think of hooking up as the book on tape, meaning that you still get most of the same things out of it, but in a much more entertaining, less time-consuming way." I am looking for some of the good parts of dating and friendship: someone to laugh with at movies, hold hands at the museum, who doesn't freak when they see you without make-up, and to fuck with till our brains freeze into silly smiles. But I don't want the love dramas, the jealousy, the commitment, and the meeting of parents. (shudder) I have never been one to fall in love accidentally, it has been a conscious decision to open the door to that possibility a few times. On the other hand, I do tend to love easily- friends, family, small children, chocolate. :) The Happy Hook-Up is much more informative and quite fascinating, though not helpful too much to this particular situation. "... There's a wealth of knowledge to be gained when you take a dip into the casual sex pool." B. taught me more about kink than you can imagine, but more importantly he taught me about expanding my mind into variations and your lover's choices too. C. taught me about intimacy, and J. reminded me to explore what sexuality and romance mean to me. Both books have small sections on sex with friends, but assume the friendship aspect proceeds the sex by a large margin. And neither book gives much time to the concept of the fuck buddy.
Hook-Up does briefly discuss the dangers of the spooning. This maybe part of where things went wrong. Spooning, cuddling for me are not necessarily romantic. After all, we do both with children all the time. Touch is not associated directly to sex for me, even with lovers. I believe in touching with love, and that being essential for health. The whole do you sleep over, does he sleep over has also never been a big deal for me. I have trouble falling asleep while touching another most of the time. Thus, I am actually more comfortable sleeping with a lover rather than someone I am in a dating relationship with. But I know this is not the norm.
Realizing I had not gotten many answers from the books, I polled several friends, two female and one male. All of them would be described as sluts by others, and by themselves, though ethical ones. Basically,they told me the sleep/cuddling was often dangerously misinterpretable. And more importantly, leaving helps avoid the walk of shame. Though my male friend, quite rightly said, I do not have much in the way of shame anyway.
Overall, I have no complete answers to this situation. I hope to spend more time with him, and get to know each other enough to trust and talk though most of the issues. After all, he was quite wonderful in bed, and very good company out of it. :)